Superior Court Judge Larry Fidler reversed course from his earlier decision in the music producer's first trial where he refused to instruct the jury that it could consider voluntary or involuntary manslaughter against Spector. That jury deadlocked 10-2 with the majority favoring conviction on second-degree murder.
Spector, 68, is accused of fatally shooting Clarkson at his home in 2003. The defense has said Clarkson, an actress who starred in the cult film "Barbarian Queen," killed herself.
The judge acknowledged that both arguments by prosecutors the defense did not suggest involuntary manslaughter, but he thought it was possible a juror could interpret the evidence pointed toward the lesser charge.
Defense attorney Doron Weinberg objected to Fidler's ruling, saying it would confuse the jury and that there was "not a shred of factual or legal support" for involuntary manslaughter.
District attorney's spokeswoman Sandi Gibbons said the judge made the ruling after prosecutors brought to his attention a precedent that allows him to give an alternative to jurors. She said they did not ask for the ruling.
"We are proceeding on the theory of second-degree murder, as we always have, and that's what we will be arguing," Gibbons said.
Closing arguments in the retrial were scheduled Monday.
© 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
James puts the supremely talented Cam Newton through a series of tests to find out how much Cam can do? Can Cam catch grapes, defend his rock-paper-scissors title and do one last dab?
Every year, CBS looks for more than a dozen people to live in a house together and compete for $500,000 on “Big Brother.” On Sunday hundreds of people gathered in Miramar to show off why they deserve to be the next houseguest on the show.
Dubai's government on Sunday forcefully denied a claim by R&B singer R. Kelly that the artist had planned concerts in the sheikhdom after he had sought permission from an Illinois judge to travel here despite facing sexual-abuse charges.
Jordan Peele has done it again. Two years after the filmmaker's "Get Out" became a box-office sensation, his frightening follow-up, "Us," debuted with $70.3 million in ticket sales, according to estimates Sunday.
Senator Doug Jones (D-AL) knows what's going up on billboards in Alabama if Jeff Sessions ever challenges his seat.
Rep. Devin Nunes is taking legal action against Twitter for allowing accounts to mock him. In other words, he's suing Twitter for being... Twitter?
'The Good Fight' star recently received the theater world's highest honor, and she'd like to dedicate it to her actor grandparents who also spent a lifetime on stage.
'The Act' star Patricia Arquette has a Robert Mueller devotional candle. No word on what it smells like.
'Better Things' star Pamela Adlon has two words for the physical changes we undergo as we age: so what?