Supreme Court to consider military medical malpractice case - CBS News 8 - San Diego, CA News Station - KFMB Channel 8

Supreme Court to consider military medical malpractice case

Posted: Updated:

SAN DIEGO/SACRAMENTO (CBS8) - The U.S. Supreme Court will consider whether to hear a case on a controversial legal doctrine that forbids active-duty personnel from suing military doctors for medical malpractice.

"A member of the service doesn't have the same rights to sue for medical malpractice as you or I would have," explains Joy Delman, a Professor at Thomas Jefferson School of Law.

Sergeant Carmelo Rodriguez and his family discovered that first hand, when the 29-year-old's skin cancer was discovered, but never reported to him.  Rodriguez later died from the cancer and the families attempt to turnover the very doctrine that defines the fact military members can't sue the federal government fizzled out in Congress.

"The theory behind it is that there are alternative mechanisms in place for compensation that military members have," said Delman.

Medical care and other service's through the Veteran's Administration is the benefit referred to in the event a military member is injured "incident to service." But many families of those affected by medical errors that resulted in the permanent damage or death of their loved ones don't think those benefits are enough.

Now the United States Supreme Court is taking closer look.  Professor Delman says in the past the court has declined to hear any challenges to the Feres Doctrine, but a new case presented to them is being considered for a possible hearing.

The challenge is being brought forward by the family of Sacramento based Airman Dean Witt, who was diagnosed with acute appendicitis. He survived the surgery only to have breathing complications, where a nurse stuck a breathing tube down his esophagus instead of his trachea. Witt's brain starved for oxygen, leaving him in a persistent vegetative state.

These situations bring up the question: should the Feres Doctrine not apply to military medical malpractice?

"Experts have argued that the rationale for it applying to Commanding Officers is very different than a medical situation and the two can be separated out," said Delman.

But the Office of Congressional Budget reports that, if allowed, an estimated 750 malpractice lawsuits would be filed annually, costing the federal government $2.7 billion over ten years.

Military commanders have argued that lawsuits would only distract service members up and down the chain of command and affect the mission.

A decision on whether the Supreme Court Justices will hear the case could come as early as Monday.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • AP Interview: Phelps has 'no desire' to return to swimming

    AP Interview: Phelps has 'no desire' to return to swimming

    Wednesday, September 20 2017 8:40 AM EDT2017-09-20 12:40:48 GMT
    AP Interview: Michael Phelps says he has 'no desire' to return to competitive swimming" but eager to those who follow in his enormous wake. 
    AP Interview: Michael Phelps says he has 'no desire' to return to competitive swimming" but eager to those who follow in his enormous wake. 
  • Chula Vista officer shoots attacker who charged with knife, both hospitalized

    Chula Vista officer shoots attacker who charged with knife, both hospitalized

    Wednesday, September 20 2017 3:18 AM EDT2017-09-20 07:18:10 GMT

    SAN DIEGO (NEWS 8) - At least two people were taken to area hospitals after a dispute between neighbors in Chula Vista led to gunfire. Chula Vista Police Department officers responded to the incident near Monterey Avene and E. J Street. in Chula Vista at around 10:28 p.m. One victim was taken to UCSD Medical Center and another was taken to Scripps Mercy Hospital. Check back for updates on this breaking news story.

     

    SAN DIEGO (NEWS 8) - At least two people were taken to area hospitals after a dispute between neighbors in Chula Vista led to gunfire. Chula Vista Police Department officers responded to the incident near Monterey Avene and E. J Street. in Chula Vista at around 10:28 p.m. One victim was taken to UCSD Medical Center and another was taken to Scripps Mercy Hospital. Check back for updates on this breaking news story.

     
  • Coronado City Council backs IB's lawsuit against IWBC without joining lawsuit

    Coronado City Council backs IB's lawsuit against IWBC without joining lawsuit

    Wednesday, September 20 2017 2:54 AM EDT2017-09-20 06:54:06 GMT

    Coronado won't be joining Imperial Beach in its federal lawsuit against the International Water and Boundary Commission, but it will assist its coastal neighbor with legal fees and lobbying with the federal government.

     

    Coronado won't be joining Imperial Beach in its federal lawsuit against the International Water and Boundary Commission, but it will assist its coastal neighbor with legal fees and lobbying with the federal government.

     
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 Midwest Television, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.