SAN DIEGO (CNS) - A panel of state appellate justices handed the city of San Diego a victory Friday in litigation over the timing of the elimination of certain pension benefits.
The City Attorney's Office had no immediate comment on the decision upholding a Superior Court ruling, penned by 4th District Court of Appeals Justice Gilbert Nares with concurrence by Justices Patricia Benke and Judith McConnell.
The case involved nearly 600 city employees hired between July 1, 2005, and Feb. 16, 2007, who were caught in limbo when San Diego eliminated four special benefits to workers.
According to court documents, city labor contracts with unions that took effect on the first date prohibited new hires from purchasing service credits that could be applied to their later retirement payouts. However, the City Council did not outlaw the practice in the municipal code until January 2007 -- with its action taking effect the next month.
The city filed suit when the San Diego City Employees Retirement System advised employees that the effective date that the benefits were abolished was February 16, 2007, not July 1, 2005, according to the documents.
The defendants, who included the affected workers, claimed the City Council could not apply the ordinance retroactively.
However, the appellate justices affirmed the lower court ruling that the City Council could rescind the benefits on the earlier date, because they weren't offered to the newer employees in their labor contracts, and thus were never vested.
Other benefits no longer offered to municipal employees after July 1, 2005, were the "13th check," in which workers could receive more money if there was a surplus in the retirement system, and the deferred retirement program, in which employees could receive some pension payments while still employed.
A North County community leader who's known as a bicycle and pedestrian safety advocate was hit by a truck and seriously injured while riding her bicycle in Encinitas early Saturday.
It's been nearly one month since a group of Central American migrants made the long trek through Mexico to the border in Tijuana. They have since been moved east, but their living conditions are still poor - so local faith leaders are calling for help.
Four people were displaced when a fire damaged their South Bay home Sunday morning, authorities said.
A prominent Los Angeles-area obstetrician has denied allegations by more than 20 former patients that he assaulted, harassed or harmed them during treatment, according to a newspaper investigation.
Dozens of people bearing flowers or stuffed animals attended a funeral for a newborn girl found dead in July along a Southern California highway.
All southbound lanes of Interstate 5 will be closed from 9:30 p.m. to 5 a.m. starting tonight and continuing through Monday, according to the San Diego Association of Governments.
A winter storm in the southeastern United States was impacting travel Sunday, causing the cancellation of more than 1,000 flights, including some to and from San Diego.
A 27-year-old man suffered non-life threatening injuries despite being shot at least eight times while walking on a sidewalk Sunday morning in the Chollas View community of San Diego.
On December 8th, 2008, tragedy struck in University City after an F-18 fighter jet came crashing down striking two homes.
One person was killed and another injured after a shooting in Mt. Hope late Saturday, but the shooter was gone by the time police got to the scene.