Court sides with Marvin Gaye family in 'Blurred Lines' fight - CBS News 8 - San Diego, CA News Station - KFMB Channel 8

Court sides with Marvin Gaye family in 'Blurred Lines' fight

Posted: Updated:

LOS ANGELES (AP) - A federal appeals court on Wednesday upheld a copyright infringement verdict against Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams over the 2013 hit song "Blurred Lines," agreeing with lower courts that it illegally copied from Marvin Gaye's "Got to Give it Up."

In a split decision from a three-judge panel, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the family of the late soul singer is entitled to the $5.3 million it was awarded in a case that has been closely watched in the music industry for its potential effects on copyright and creativity.

Two judges rejected the defense's request to overturn a jury verdict or order a new trial, saying that Gaye's copyright on the song is entitled to broad protection. They accepted a trial court judge's instructions to jurors to decide the case based only on the sheet music to the two songs, and not the recordings.

Judge Jacqueline Nguyen offered a harsh dissent, saying that the two R&B tunes resemble each other only in style not substance and that the decision was detrimental to the future of artists and creativity.

"The majority allows the Gayes to accomplish what no one has before: copyright a musical style," Nguyen wrote. "'Blurred Lines' and 'Got to Give It Up' are not objectively similar. They differ in melody, harmony, and rhythm. Yet by refusing to compare the two works, the majority establishes a dangerous precedent that strikes a devastating blow to future musicians and composers everywhere."

Howard King, an attorney for Williams and Thicke, seized on Nguyen's comments.

"We stand by the fact that these are two entirely different songs," King said in an email to The Associated Press. "The thorough and well-reasoned dissenting judge's opinion is compelling and enhances the prospects for success in a further review by the Court of Appeals."

The Gaye family's attorney Richard S. Busch praised the ruling. "Despite the protests of the Williams' camp that the decision somehow stifles creativity, the opposite is true," he said in a statement. He said the verdict and Wednesday's ruling "encourages today's writers to create original work that does not take advantage of the success of others while pawning it off as their own."

The court also upheld a jury's verdict that hip-hop artist T.I., who raps in the middle of the song, and Interscope Records, are not liable for damages in the case.

While artists normally fall firmly on the side of greater copyright protections, many lined up behind Thicke and Williams in this appeal.

R. Kelley, composer Hans Zimmer and members of The Go-Go's and The Black Crowes were among more than 200 musicians who jointly filed a brief in favor of the defendants, saying the ruling could have an "adverse impact on their own creativity, on the creativity of future artists, and on the music industry in general."

The trial over "Blurred Lines," the biggest hit of 2013, ended in March 2015 with jurors awarding Gaye's family more than $7 million. The verdict was later trimmed to $5.3 million. The Gaye family also received 50 percent interest in ongoing royalties from the song.

RELATED COVERAGE

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press.

  • Entertainment NewsEntertainment NewsMore>>

  • The Latest: Cosby accusers say he got what he deserved

    The Latest: Cosby accusers say he got what he deserved

    Tuesday, September 25 2018 8:42 AM EDT2018-09-25 12:42:18 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 7:44 PM EDT2018-09-25 23:44:46 GMT
    (AP Photo/Matt Slocum). Bill Cosby arrives for his sentencing hearing at the Montgomery County Courthouse, Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2018, in Norristown, Pa.(AP Photo/Matt Slocum). Bill Cosby arrives for his sentencing hearing at the Montgomery County Courthouse, Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2018, in Norristown, Pa.
    Bill Cosby doesn't plan to make a statement in court before he's sentenced for drugging and sexually assaulting a woman. 
    Bill Cosby doesn't plan to make a statement in court before he's sentenced for drugging and sexually assaulting a woman. 
  • Actor Will Smith makes birthday bungee jump near Grand Canyon

    Actor Will Smith makes birthday bungee jump near Grand Canyon

    Tuesday, September 25 2018 7:28 PM EDT2018-09-25 23:28:10 GMT

    Will Smith is diving head first into turning 50.

     

    Will Smith is diving head first into turning 50.

     
  • Michael Kors ups the glamour, buys Versace for $2 billion

    Michael Kors ups the glamour, buys Versace for $2 billion

    Tuesday, September 25 2018 7:32 AM EDT2018-09-25 11:32:39 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 7:13 PM EDT2018-09-25 23:13:13 GMT
    (AP Photo/Richard Drew, File). FILE- In this May 31, 2017, file photo the Michael Kors name adorns his store on Madison Avenue, in New York. Michael Kors is buying the Italian fashion house Gianni Versace in a deal worth more than $2 billion in a hard ...(AP Photo/Richard Drew, File). FILE- In this May 31, 2017, file photo the Michael Kors name adorns his store on Madison Avenue, in New York. Michael Kors is buying the Italian fashion house Gianni Versace in a deal worth more than $2 billion in a hard ...
    Seeking more glitter, Michael Kors is buying the Italian fashion house Gianni Versace in a deal worth more than $2 billion. 
    Seeking more glitter, Michael Kors is buying the Italian fashion house Gianni Versace in a deal worth more than $2 billion. 
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 KFMB-TV. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.