Breaking News
More () »

News 8’s Unknown Reporter: New details on Earl McNeil’s death following arrest by National City police

A murder 30 years ago on 41st Street in southeastern San Diego was a defining moment in the life Earl McNeil.
News 8’s Unknown Reporter: New details on Earl McNeil’s death following arrest by National City police

NATIONAL CITY, CA (NEWS 8) - A murder 30 years ago on 41st Street in southeastern San Diego was a defining moment in the life of Earl McNeil.

News 8 archive footage from 1988 shows the scene where - at the age of 11 - McNeil witnessed his mother get shot in the head and killed in the street during a random drive-by shooting.


11-year-old Earl McNeil (1988 News 8 archive)

One year later, the 12-year-old boy committed his first residential burglary, according to court records, and was declared a ward of the San Diego County Juvenile Court.

Diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, McNeil started hearing voices and tried to hang himself two times in juvenile hall, according to a 2000 psychological evaluation filed in San Diego County Superior Court.

From there, you can't sugar coat the criminal history of Earl McNeil.

He’s a former Skyline Blood gang member with convictions for robbery, grand theft, possession of drugs, and statutory rape (when McNeil was age 22). He has domestic violence cases in three different counties.

McNeil was sentenced to prison three times, most recently in 2016 for burglary and possession of a firearm.


Earl McNeil, 2012 booking photos

Now, fast forward to May 26 of this year.

The 40-year-old McNeil is on the front porch of the National City Police Department at 5:30 a.m., apparently high on methamphetamine.

He picks up a police hotline on the exterior of the building, setting off a sequence of events where he ends up hospitalized. Eventually, he is taken off life support and dies.

National City Police Chief Manuel Rodriguez agreed to talk to News 8 about what happened that morning.

“He called us, said he was high, exhibited the signs of being under the influence and had meth on him,” said Chief Rodriguez.


National City Police Chief Manuel Rodriguez talks to News 8

“The officers take him into custody, put him on the ground, and put him in the (body) wrap,” he said.

“The whole episode took about two hours. There were about five officers involved in the wrap itself. He starts spitting on them. They put a spit mask on him,” the chief said.

Officers then put McNeil in a patrol car and drove around the corner into the department's underground sally port.

“He was driven in and he wasn't taken out of the car,” Rodriguez said.

For more than an hour, police kept McNeil in the car, restrained, while they checked on his criminal record and probation status, according to the chief.

“He was kept in the wrap until we got him to county jail,” the chief said.

On the drive to the downtown jail, the chief said McNeil continued to flail around in the back seat, hitting his head against the inside of the vehicle.

Upon arrival at the San Diego Central Jail, which is run by the San Diego County Sheriff’s Department, McNeil was still agitated.

He went into medical distress and stopped breathing, according to Chief Rodriguez.

Officer body-cam video and surveillance video from both the National City Police Department and the downtown jail captured the entire incident from start to finish, Rodriguez said.

“In the portions that I've seen, in the video, the officers do not use any batons and do not use any strikes,” said Rodriguez, “No punches, no kicks.”

McNeil's death has led to protests and demands for National City police to release the body-cam video.

The chief said he cannot promise when or if the video will be made public.

“The district attorney has to review it. We have to do an internal investigation and I cannot promise you, because if there's a lawsuit as a result of this, that may prevent release of that video,” he said.

Other police agencies, like El Cajon, have released video in high-profile police shooting cases. 

Rodriguez said this case is different because there are hours of video from at least four different body cameras.

“This is not an officer-involved shooting. There isn't a moment in time where releasing any part of the video is going to help people. But that evaluation will continue,” he said.

Chief Rodriguez said his department is reviewing all the video, and the footage also has been turned over to the district attorney’s office.

The San Diego County Medical Examiner’s report is expected by the end of the month.


Before You Leave, Check This Out